
A Study of the Pet
Food Fallacy
by Ann Martin
Proteins are the building blocks of life and
must be of good quality in order to sustain it. To survive, your
cherished animal companion must be provided with proteins. The
pet food industry would have us believe that their foods provide
a "complete and balanced diet" for our pets. In reality what we
are feeding are the dregs of the human food chain, garbage unfit
for human or animal consumption.
What do these proteins consist of and how
good are they ? If you really want to know the truth read on
...., if you're not ready for it, you had better stop now.
Animal proteins consist of diseased meat,
road kills, contaminated material from slaughterhouses, fecal
matter, euthanized cats and dogs, poultry feathers, all prepared
together as rendered material. Yes, these are the sources of
animal protein presently used in many commercial pet foods.
Vegetable proteins, often the mainstay of dry
foods include ground yellow corn, wheat shorts and middlings,
soybean meal, rice hulks and peanut meal. All provide very
little nutritional value and are nothing more than sweepings and
offal from milling room floors left over after processing. The
removal of the oil, germ, bran, starch and gluten from those
grains eliminate the essential fatty acids and a number of fat
soluble vitamins and antioxidants.
The animal proteins used in these foods come
from a number of different sources. Dead stock removal
operations provide the "4-D" animals: Dead, Diseased,, Dying or
Disabled. Most have died or are dying from causes unknown and
have been treated with a wide array of drugs before given a
lethal injection of a potent drug to euthanize them. The animals
are then delivered to a "receiving plant" where the hide (sold
to a tannery), skin, fats and meat are removed. The meat from
these animals can be sold for pet food after it is completely
covered in charcoal (to prevent ingestion by humans)*, and
marked "unfit for human consumption".
If the animal arrives at the "receiving
plant" in a state of decomposition it is transported to a
rendering plant along with road kill which is too large to be
buried along the road side. Next we have the condemned material
from slaughterhouses. Animals that have died on their way to
slaughter, diseased animals or parts, diseased blood,
extraneaous matter, hair, feet, head, mammary glands, carpal and
tarsal joints or any part of the animal comdemned for human
consumption can be rendered for pet food. Before this material
leaves the slaughterhouse, it is "denatured" (doused with
chemicals) to prevent it from getting back into the human food
chain when being transported to the rendering facilities.
In Canada the material used to "denature" is
Birkolene b. According to the Department of Agriculture, Animal
Plant and Health, the composition of this chemical cannot be
disclosed. In the U.S. a number of agents can be used including
carbolic acid, fuel or kerosene and citronella.
We now have animal protein classified as
"4-D's", road kill and condemned material from the
slaughterhouse. Another source of animal protein which the
industry vehemently deny they use, are rendered companion
animals.
Dogs and cats euthanized at clinics, pounds
and shelters are sold to rendering plants, rendered with other
material and sold to the pet food industry. One small rendering
plant in Quebec was rendering 10 tonnes (11 tons) of dogs and
cats per week from Ontario. The Ministry of Agriculture in
Quebec, where a number of these plants are located, advised me
that "The fur is not removed from dogs and cats and that "Dead
animals are cooked together with viscera, bones and fats in 115C
(236F) for twenty minutes." One large pet food company in the
U.S., with extensive research facilities, used rendered dogs and
cats in their food for years and when the information came to
light "claimed no knowledge of it." The Food and Drug
Administration, Center for Veterinary Medicine, in the U.S., is
aware of the use of rendered companion animals in pet food and
has stated, "CVM has not acted to specifically prohibit the
rendering of pets. However, that is not to say that the practice
of using this material in pet food is condoned by CVM." In a
research paper from the University of Minnesota entitled "Fats
of Sodium Pentobarbital in Rendered Products", it stated that
the barbiturate, sodium pentobarbital, which is used to
euthanize small animals, "survived rendering without undergoing
degradation."
In the U.S., as in Canada, the pet food
industry is virtually self-regulated. In the U.S. the AAFCO
(Association of American Feed Control Officials) sets guidelines
and definitions for animal feed ingredients including pet foods.
It is up to each State to adopt and enforce these guidelines.
The AAFCO states that there are no restrictions on the type of
animals which can be used in meals, tankage, digests, etc....
Any kind of animal can be used including cats and dogs.
The AAFCO "Official Publication", "Feed
Ingredient Definitions" is extensive and lists what can be used
in animal feeds. The list includes "Spray Dried Animal Blood",
"Hydrolyzed Hair", "Dehydrated Garbage", "Unborn Calf
Carcasses", "Dried Poultry Litter (means processed animal waste
product composed of a processed combination of feces from
commercial poultry together with litter that was present in the
floor production of poultry)", "Dried Ruminant Waste", "Dried
Swine Waste", "Undried Processed Animal Waste Products (means a
processed animal waste product composed of excreta, with or
without litter, from poultry, ruminants or any other animal
except humans)", and the list goes on. I asked if these
definitions applied to only livestock feed and was advised that
these guidelines and definitions also apply to pet foods.
In Canada there are virtually no regulations
in this industry. Other then the "Labeling Act", which states
that the label must contain the name and address of the company,
weight of the product and if it is made for a dog or cat, there
are no set standards. The CVMA (Canadian Veterinary Medical
Association) and PFAC (Pet Food Association of Canada) are
voluntary organizations and for the most part rely on the
integrity of the company which they certify, stating that the
ingredients are not below the minimal standards set. Of all the
pet food sold in Canada, 85-90% is manufactured by the
multi-nationals in te U.S. and neither the CVMA or PFAC have any
control over the ingredients used in these foods.
The sad scenario is that it is our pets who
are suffering the ills of these inferior ingredients, the lack
of a nutritious diet. We have been brainwashed by the industry
and some veterinarians, that in order to keep our pets healthy
we must feed them a diet formulated for dogs and cats. NO TABLE
SCRAPS ! We have pets suffering from cancer, skin problems,
allergies, hypertension, kidney and liver failure, heart
disease, numerous dental problems, to name but a few. These same
individuals can find a myriad of reasons why our pets are
inflicted with these problems, the environment, lack of exercise
and stress, but never is it attributed to the inferior
commercial foods we are feeding. Before the pet industry began
to prosper, our pets ate what we did and lived long, happy
lives. Most died of old age.
So, if you love and care about your pet, take
a few extra minutes when preparing your meal, add a litlle more
meat, toss in a few more vegetables, cook a little more brown
rice or oatmeal, even a piece of toast. At least you'll know
what your pet is eating and I am sure you will see an end to the
escalating veterinary bills and have a happier, healthier pet.
The Pet Food Industry, a billion dollar
unregulated industry, has evolved from the garbage which would
otherwise be disposed of at a land fill site, buried or
processed into fertilizer. Our pets are ingesting this stuff on
a daily basis. Garbage, laced with additives, preservatives (of
a questionable nature), chemicals, excess amounts of sugar and
sodium (nearly three teaspoons of salt per kg. of food), and
according to the AAFCO ingredient definitions, "Urea
Formaldehyde".
I suggest that one addition be made to the
labelling of pet foods, a skull and cross-bone insignia on the
package.
RESOURCE:
(1) The AAFCO "Official Publication" 1993
(2) The Ontario "Dead Animal Disposal Act".
(3) The Minister of Agriculture, Quebec. (letter stating how
dogs and cats are rendered)
(4) The Quebec "Inedible Boned Meat Act".
(5) "Pet Food Certification Program" CVMA.
(6) Letters from the FDA, Center for Veterinary Medicine.
* In Canada, charcoal is always used to "denature"
meat which is sold by "receiving plants". Apparently some people
were buying it not realizing the condition of the animal it came
from, and eating it. The reason that charcoal is used is that it
deters people from eating it but it won't harm the animal that
is ingesting the stuff.
Editor's note: Charcoal is an antidote and is
used by many meat packers when there is a question of chemical
residue.
This article first appeared in the
March/April 1995 issue of "Natural Pet" and the editor adds this
note:
Ann Martin has been working on this for over four years. She and
I have corresponded for over one year and have established a
well documented trail from various governmental sources
attesting to this atrocity. In the interim there are animals who
will suffer the consequences of inferior food and we can't do
anything about it - or can we ? Your comments are welcomed.
Haut
Feeding spot
Advice from Nutritionally Oriented
Veterinarians
by Martin Zucker
Pet food
manufacturers spend well over $ 160 million a year pitching
their goods to the pet-owning public. That may seem like a lot
of money, but the stakes are high: $ 5 billion a year in sales.
The array of products offered at pet stores
and supermarkets can be confusing, so LET'S LIVE asked
nutritionally oriented veterinarians for some advice. Here's
what they had to say:
Dr. Carvel Tiekert, of Bel Air, Maryland,
president of the American Veterinary Hollistic Medical
Association, rates food on a 10-point scale.
Near the bottom in quality and nutrition is
the commercial semi-moist food. "I give it a two," Dr. Tiekert
said. "It is as close to garbage as you can get - full of sugar,
propylene glycol and other chemical additives.
"Next, a little better at about three and a
half, come the cheap, generic (non-name brands) foods. They are
infamous for mineral deficiencies, particularly zinc.
"At about five or six come most name brands.
They are adequate, but not optimal. They are reasonably
well-researched, but quality comes second to price. They are
made to be competitive and are usually loaded with chemicals.
"At about eight come the top name brands.
They have higher quality ingredients and nutrients.
"I rate the all-natural pet foods at nine.
These high-quality products have no preservatives, chemicals
additives, or sugar.
"At 10, the very best, is the home-made diet.
You can't do better for your animal. As far as supplementation
is concerned, I suggest all animals get extra vitamin C and E.
Dr. Alfred Plechner, of Los Angeles, has a
special interest in food alergies and is the author of Pet
Allergies: Remedies For An Epidemic. Dr. Plechner believes there
is a widespread intolerance to commercial food among many
animals. This rejection is expressed as violent illness or
chronic health problems, and often triggers a hypersensitivity
and overreaction to flea and insect bites, pollens, soaps,
sprays, and environmental contaminents.
"Dry food, said Dr. Plechner, is a major
offender because it is "a concentrated collection of many of the
foods that are the most allergenic for animals. It usually also
contains excessive amounts of inferior protein.
"Stay away from high-protein dry food. Your
animals' bodies don't need extra amounts of poor-quality
protein.
"Many dogs are allergic to beef, and many
cats are sensitive to tuna. If you suspect a food allergy, try
feeding them lamb and rice or chicken and rice for a week or so.
I have found these foods to be the least problematic.
"If your animals do well, you can add other
foods singly for a week and look for reactions. In that way, you
can soon develop an individualized hypoallergenic menu for your
animal.
"If you don't want to go to the trouble of
preparing meals yourself, then ask your veterinarian, pet store,
or health food store for high-quality hypoallergenic diets.
Dr. Wendell O. Belfield, of San Jose,
California, is author of How to Have a Healthier Dog and The
Very Healthy Cat Book. While researching the information for his
books, he investigated pet-food manifacturing procedures and
found many disturbing facts. Among the shockers: A considerable
amount of diseased animal tissue, hair, claws, feathers, beaks,
and slaughterhouse rejects are used.
"You're not getting sirloin steak", he said.
"Ingredients are put through chemical heat and pressure
processes to render them commercially sterile. But that doesn't
improve original quality and probably doesn't eliminate
pesticides and herbicides that killed many of the livestock used
for pet food.
"Despite industry claims that pets live long
and healthy lives on commercial pet food, we vets are routinely
faced with contradictory evidence in the form of sick animals."
His advice:
- Read labels. Don't buy products with
additives such as BHA, sodium nitrite, propylene glycol and
artificial coloring.
- Supplement your animals for optimal health.
Vitamin and mineral fortification in pet food usually provides
merely minimal levels of nutritents.
Dr. John Limehouse, of North Hollywood,
California, recommends a home-made diet that is steam-cooked and
consists of 50 percent brown rice, 25 percent meat, and 25
percent vegetables. Cats shoud have about 60 percent meat,
either raw or cooked. If an animal has skin conditions or is
hyperactive, Dr. Limehouse suggests white meats. If an animal is
run down and tends to be cold, he suggests red meats.
He cautions about using organ meats, such as
liver or kidney, because of the residues of pesticides and heavy
meats that may be diposited in these parts.
Recommended vegetables are broccoli and beans
if an animal is often cold, or zucchini, potatoes, carrots and
turnips if it has skin conditions.
"Supplementation is important, particularly
if you feed an animal commercial food. remember that to-day's
food is grown in depleted soil. Animals, as well as people, can
benefit from the extra nutrition.
"I believe that cats who eat all day tend to
be overweight and less healthy," said Dr. Limehouse. "I tell my
clients not to allow their cats free-choice food. Rather, they
should come to you, make a fuss and meow for their food. Let
them ask for it once or twice a day, according to their
individual needs and expressed appetite."
Dr. Michael Lemmon, of Renton, Washington,
also warns pet owners about overfeeding their animals.
"Most Americans feed their animals too much,"
he said. "And that can lead to health problems. Leave the food
for 15 or 20 minutes in the morning. Then take it away. Do the
same thing in the evening.
"For one thing, overfeeding creates
alkalinity in the urine. In cats that is undesirable and may
possibly be a factor in the development of urinary tract stones,
a common feline problem. It is best to keep a tight rein on both
the frequency and amount of feedings.
Dr. Marty Goldstein, of South Salem, New
York, urges pet owners not to get "fanatic" about their animals'
health.
"Some people I know even test pH balance. If
it is just a tad off they become desperate, ring my office as if
there were an emergency and want to know what they can do," said
Dr. Goldstein.
"It is okay to be concerned about an animal's
health and provide the best possible care and diet, but ease up
some. Health has its variables. Long-term quality is more
important than daily fluctuations, which may be the result of
natural detoxification and cycles.
"Keep your animal on a diet that has variety.
Use good food without chemicals. Prepare meats, grains, and
vegetables and add them to commercial food or use them alone.
"For general maintenance of a healthy animal,
I recommend a good multivitamin and mineral formula along,
perhaps, with a little extra vitamin C and E. For the healthy
animal, fasting one day a week is not a bad idea.
Footnote: For the name of a nutritionally
oriented veterinarian near you, send a self-addressed, stamped
envelope to the American Veterinary Hollistic Medical
Association, 2214 Old Emmerton Rd., Bel Air, MD 21014